My 1st Day with the Kindle 3
Well, it was a few days late, but I finally got my Kindle today. As I knew I would be, I love the updated screen, the new button placement and smaller form factor. Looking at the Kindle 2 and Kindle 3 side-by-side shows off my new Kindle to advantage.
There are a plethora of positive reviews, comparison videos and comparison reviews out there so I won’t go into any of those details. You can google for those, or if you want a really thorough video comparison, Len Edgerly of The Kindle Chronicles has a great one. Unfortunately, I am going to talk about the features that I don’t feel are an improvement, and a couple of items that I think should be changed right away.
Number Keys
(Edit: I’ve been advised to hold down the ALT key to do the below, but I’m still not happy with the removal of the numbered row)
At first, I was resigned to accessing numbers via the SYM key. It would be a little inconvenient, but I was willing to overlook it to have the smaller size. Not any longer. The lack of a row for the numbers means that if you plan on storing more than a couple of pages of content, you are almost forced to use collections and it is an example of bad design.
Example:
On the Kindle 2, if you have a lot of pages, you can use the number keys to enter the number, and click to go to that page.
On the Kindle 3, you have to enter a letter, click the DEL key to remove it and then use the SYM key to enter the page number. If Amazon has a UI expert, that one definitely slipped thru the cracks, but I’m pretty sure this can be solved with a software update adding the Go To item to the Home menu.
Wi-Fi/3G
There is no way to turn either off separate from the other. Turning off wireless means both get turned off. This is a pretty minor issue, but without an explanation of how/when 3G and/or Wi-Fi are accessed by the device, I’m left wondering how either setting on is affecting battery life.
Headphone/Speaker jack
Why, oh why is this on the bottom of the device? If my device is on a stand or in my lap, that means that I’m going to have to bend the cord at an angle that will eventually break the wire. It belongs back on the top or even on the side of the Kindle.
Volume bar
See above reaction. This too should be moved back to the side of the device or up on top. My vote is the side, but I’ll be happy with either.
——————————
Okay–done with the griping. On to the things that I love.
Font Settings
Yay for the sans serif font! I won’t need to use the font hack any longer. Unfortunately, it doesn’t work for those awful topaz formatted books, but we can’t have everything.
Weight
I know that some of the reviews stated that you can’t tell the difference in weight between the Kindle 2 and Kindle 3, but I can. And I know that anyone with weight sensitive hands and/or wrists will appreciate the marked (to me, anyway) difference in weight.
Top Bar
When you 0pen a book, you can see the Title, Time and wireless status on the top bar, but as soon as you turn the page, they disappear to make more room for the text of the book. At first, I didn’t like it , but as I’ve been reading, I appreciate the extra text. I wish it worked the same on waking the device up. If you read more than one book at a time, you won’t know (without skimming the page) which book you are in.
Contrast
This has been said over and over, but it is so improved that it can’t be overstated. The Kindle 3 screen is very crisp; I can’t get over how good it looks.
All in all, I am very happy and satisfied with the Kindle 3. Amazon did a lot of small improvements that really add up to a big improvement overall. Well that’s it for me, its back to reading on Mr. Slate. He’s naked now, but I’m expecting the Amazon cover tomorrow.










